On October 30, 2024, the Japan IP High Court disaffirmed the administrative decision by the Japan Patent Office (JPO) not to register the 3D shape of the eponymous character from the film “Shin Godzilla” as a trademark.
[Judicial case no. Riewa6(Gyo-ke)10047]
GODZILLA
Godzilla, a science-fiction monster spawned from the waste of nuclear tests that resembles an enormous bipedal lizard was released in Japanese film in 1954. The character has since become an international pop culture icon. After the original 1954 cinematic masterpiece, Godzilla has appeared in more than 30 films spanning seven decades and several eras produced by Toho Co., Ltd.
On July 29, 2016, the film “Shin Godzilla (Godzilla Resurgence)” produced by Toho was theatrically released as a 31st film of Godzilla trilogy. The film grossed $79 million worldwide, making it the highest-grossing live-action Japanese film of 2016. It received 11 Japan Academy Prize nominations and won seven, including Picture of the Year and Director of the Year.
Toho Co. filed a trademark application with the JPO for the 3D shape of Godzilla’s fourth form in the film “Shin Godzilla”, the final evolutionary form of the character appearing in the film, as a trademark for use in stuffed toys, figures, dolls and toys of class 28 on September 29, 2020 (TM App no. 2020-120003).
The JPO examiner, however, rejected the 3D mark based on Article 3(1)(iii) of the Trademark Law due to a lack of distinctiveness in relation to the goods. The JPO Appeal Board also dismissed an appeal on the same ground and held that the 3D shape has not acquired distinctiveness because of insufficient use of the 3D mark in relation to the goods in question (Appeal case no. 2021-11555).
On May 10, 2024, Toho filed an appeal to the IP High Court and called for the JPO decision to be revoked.
IP High Court decision
The IP High Court affirmed the findings of the JPO to reject the 3D shape due to a lack of inherent distinctiveness in relation to the goods in question.
In the meantime, the court found that the JPO errored in applying Article 3(2) and assessing the acquired distinctiveness of the 3D mark by stating that:
- Toho has produced and distributed 30 films in the “Godzilla” series over a 69-year period from 1954 to 2023, and although the shape of the “Godzilla” character in these films changed slightly, the basic shape of the character was largely the same, and the form of the Godzilla character with its countless folds and complex rocklike texture is distinctive among other monster characters of the same type.
- The applied mark represents the 3D shape of Godzilla’s fourth form in the film “Shin Godzilla”, the final evolutionary form of the character appearing in the film. It has the same features with the monster appeared in the previous “Godzilla” films. It is obvious that the basic shape of the “Godzilla” character has been widely recognized among general public to indicate a monster character produced by Toho even before the release of the film “Shin Godzilla”.
- Even if the term “use” under Article 3(2) of the Trademark Law should be limited to actual use of a sign strictly identical with the applied mark, in determining whether a consumer has come to “recognize the goods bearing the applied mark to indicate a specific source” under the article, it should be reasonable or rather necessary to consider the influence of the entire “Godzilla” films including “Shin Godzilla” on consumers’ recognition to the applied 3D mark.
- The interview conducted in September, 2021, targeting 1,000 interviewees of men and women aged 15 to 69 nationwide, showed an extremely high level of recognition, namely, 64.4% answered “Godzilla” or “Shin Godzilla” to the open-ended responses (70.8% among men).